16th April 2015


 Issue No.  2015/05



National Minimum Wage and Recovery of Training Fees

It is well established law that an employee should be paid at least the National Minimum Wage (NMW).When determining whether or not an employee has received the NMW, certain payments and deductions must be taken into account when calculating the employee’s average hourly rate of pay, which should be equal to, or more than, the prevailing NMW rate (see Information Update 2015/01).

An issue before the courts recently was whether a deduction from an employee’s final salary payment, in accordance with a separate Training Fees Agreement, was permissible. This effectively meant that the employee was being paid less than the NMW in the reference period.

In this case, the employer agreed to fund training courses providing the employees signed a Training Fees Agreement to repay some or all of the cost if they left within 2 years. The employee resigned and left within 2 years and the employer made a deduction from the employee’s final salary in accordance with the terms of the Training Fee Agreement which meant that for the final reference period, the employee was effectively paid less than the NMW.

HMRC issued a Notice of Underpayment, which the employer appealed.

The issue was whether the money deducted came within regulation 33(a) of the National Minimum Wage Regulations 1999 and in particular whether the liability to repay was "in respect of conduct of the worker, or any other event, in respect of which he is contractually liable".

The Employment Tribunal found that regulation 33(a) did apply and therefore allowed the employer’s appeal against the HMRC Notice of Underpayment. HMRC appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT). 

The EAT held, a voluntary resignation or damage to property for which the worker is responsible would come within the concept of "any other event".  Consequently, in the current case, because the employee resigned, the employer was entitled to deduct monies due in accordance with the Training Fees Agreement even though it would take the employee below the NMW in the reference period.  However, the EAT did say that it would not be the case if the employer was dismissing the employee by reason of redundancy or potentially in the case of ill health dismissals for which the worker could not be said to be responsible.

What does this mean?

When calculating an employee’s final payment, where there is a Training Fees Agreement in place; and you are seeking to deduct monies under the terms of that Agreement from any final salary payment: you should seek legal advice.  Whether a deduction can be made will be dependent upon the reason for termination and whether such a deduction would take the employee below the prevailing NMW.

If a deduction cannot be made from the employee’s final pay, it means that you would need to request payment from the employee and hope they pay it!  The alternative will be to commence proceedings in the courts to recover those costs – whether that is commercially viable to pursue will be dependent upon the amounts involved and whether the employee is likely to have the monies to pay any court judgment obtained!





Employment Law
Health & Safety
Personnel / HR
Food Safety
Food Hygiene
Management Training







Making sense of it all


Sentient - Training


Sentient adj ...

"capable of perception"

"capable of independent thought"


Can we help you?
If you think so, please contact us at advice@sentientuk.co.uk or call UK 08456 446006

To subscribe for these E-mails click here or to access our archive of previous E-mail Updates please click here.  

Click here for details of the services available on our website. 

Our current Open Course Training Programme is available to view here

Follow us on Twitter @SentientUk

The advice and comment in this update is not meant to be an authoritative statement of law. The articles and summaries should not be applied to any specific set of facts and circumstances without seeking further advice. Whilst every care is taken to ensure that the content is correct Sentient cannot accept responsibility for the accuracy of statements made nor the result of any actions taken by individuals after reading such.

To unsubscribe to this information newsletter please click here and complete the unsubscribe form on our site.
Warning do not click this link unless you wish to be removed from this update newsletter.